Jan 052016
 

Forgotten Core Feats (Revised)

133445

This pdf clocks in at 10 pages, 1 page front cover, 1 page editorial, 1.5 page SRD, leaving us with 6.5 pages of content, so let’s take a look!

 

Without an introduction, but thankfully with a table that lists the feats herein, we delve right into the meat of this book, so what do we get? Feats. A lot of them.

 

-Boon Pack: Animal companions and familiars are treated as druid level +2, up to a max of character level. Stacks with boon companion. Essentially a second feat for a total of up to +6 levels animal companion/familiar progression. Nice for multiclass-chars.

 

-Cunning: For every HD beyond 3rd, you gain +1 skill rank. If you gain a level beyond 3rd, you gain +1 skill rank. Toughness for skills. Simple, elegant, like it.

 

-Improved Cunning: Gain HD skill ranks. Get +1 skill rank per HD. Same as above – neat.

 

-Curious: +3 class skills. Rogue can take it as rogue talent. Okay for skill-starved classes.

 

-Defensive: +2 to CMD and +2 dodge bonus to AC. Bonus is lost when losing Dex-bonus to AC.

 

-Efficient Crafter: Reduce magic item creation cost by 10%, craft magic items in half the time. This is much more powerful than you’d think. Crafting is already something you can do pretty quickly and reducing the gold it costs can be nasty if your players are like mine and craft a lot. In such contexts, this may be problematic. In others, it may be very useful.

 

-Exotic Hunter’s Bond: Choose from druid companion list in addition to the ranger’s list.

 

-Exotic Weapon Group Proficiency: Requires one exotic weapon proficiency (which many races get via racial weapons): Adds +2 exotic weapon proficiencies. I get the intent of this feat, but parts of its prereqs, which are used to balance the feat, are invalidated by racial weapon proficiencies, thus rewarding all races but humans. Not a fan and pretty sure this does not work as intended.

 

-Expanded Bloodrager Spell List: +1 sorc spell per spell level to bloodrager spell list. Can be taken multiple times. Oh boy. For one, massive scavenging in one of the most powerful spell-lists. Secondly, does this make the spell known for the bloodrager or not? I assume the latter (the feat already being OP), but slightly more precision would be nice. Also: Can the class learn a spell that is both on bloodrager and sorceror lists at different levels, preparing the spell at two different levels? Not gonna get anywhere near my table.

 

-Expanded Paladin Spell list: Same deal as with bloodrager, only allows for cleric-spell-scavenging. Less powerful in comparison, but still problematic.

 

-Expanded Ranger Spell List: Same as the above, only for rangers receiving druid spells. Same criticisms as for palas apply, with the note that rangers getting druid crowd control being pretty nasty, nastier than the pala-feat (since palas already have pretty elite buffs…).

 

-Expert Tumbler: Lacks a verb. Lets the character ignore Str-mod and size modifiers regarding Acrobatics DCs to move through threatened areas. This is situational, but when it comes into play, extremely powerful -most dragons and giants won’t be able to hit a character using this feat reliably. I like the visuals…however, I think one of the two modifiers would have been more appropriate for one feat. Either you love this one, or you’ll hate the bouncy agile character further mitigating the threat of big Str-based threats.

 

-Extended Wildshape: Double wildshape duration. Yeah, you read right. For one feat. BROKEN in some contexts, useless in others. Next.

 

-Firearm Mastery: Reload a firearm as a free action. Requires Point Blank Shot, Rapid Shot and Rapid Reload. Broken as F***. This horrid piece of crunch eliminates the balancing mechanism of firearms and surpasses quite a few class abilities in power. One of the most broken feats I’ve seen in a while.

 

-Goliath Grip: Wield a weapon one size larger at -2 to atk and “the amount of effort it takes to use the weapon increases” – it’s clear due to the example what’s meant: 1-handed weapons become two-handed. I applaud what this tries to do regarding weapon-class etc….but what about finesse weapons? Can they still be finesse’d? Do one-handed light weapons become 1-handed regular weapons or 2-handed weapons? A precise sequence is required to make this feat work properly.

 

-Improved Combat Reflexes: +2 AoOs per round. Nice.

 

-Greater Combat Reflexes: +2 AoOs per round, +2 to atk with AoOs. No complaints here.

 

-Greater Unarmed Strike: Damage of unarmed strikes as monk of 1/2 character’s level; monks or brawlers instead add +1.5 Str-mod to unarmed strike damage rolls. Nice one!

 

-Half-Blood: Gain an alternate racial trait of your race or a standard racial trait of another race. This comes with a GM-approval disclaimer…the only reason I’m not frothing right now. Still, not all racial traits have the same value and the hand-waving of this feat is just sloppy, highly problematic design.

 

-Impressive Strike: When hitting critically, you deal + sneak attack damage. Not a fan, since crit-fishing agile builds can be pretty nasty. Still, the rogue can use it.

 

-Improved Combat Expertise: Decrease penalty of Combat Expertise by 2. Solid.

 

-Improved Favored Class: Gain two favored class bonuses each time you take a level. Benefits are retroactive. This feat is okay when restricted to hp and skills…but it’s not. It can be used to get much quicker access to fraction-based favored class options, halving e.g. the levels it takes to gain +1/6-based FCOs. Broken, not gonna get near my group.

 

-Improved Flank: +1 damage versus foes you flank, increasing by +1 at 4th level, +1 every 4 levels thereafter.

 

-Improved Furious Focus: When wielding a two-handed weapon or a one-handed weapon in two hands while using Power Attack, you do not suffer Power Attack’s penalty (but still do so for your AoOs). Power Attack is already one of the strongest feats in the CORE-rules. It does not need this feat, which also eliminates its tactical component – with it, you simply ALWAYS Power Attack. No decision, no tactics, gets nowhere near my table. Undermines the base-feat’s intention, which is bad game design in my book.

 

-Improved Toughness: Gain 1 Hp per HD. gain +1 HP whenever you gain a HD. Okay.

 

-Improved Turning: Deal channel energy damage to undead you turn. Has a good idea – but mitigates the save usually allocated to channel energy, so no negating on a successful Will-save RAW. Can be easily salvaged, but broken as presented.

 

-Improvised Weapon Proficiency: You’re proficient with improvised weapons and get +1 to atk with them. Also doubles as Weapon Focus for prereq-purposes. Unfortunate overlap with Improvised Weapon mastery, which increases the base damage. On the plus-side, the Weapon Focus-caveat is something Paizo’s feat should have had. Still, pretty useless.

 

-Intuitive Spellcaster: Gain +4 caster levels, up to a maximum of your HD. Can be taken multiple times to apply to different spellcasting classes. EDIT: I wholeheartedly believe in standing up to my own failings – so there you go: I colossally, terribly and unforgivably misread this feat in a titanic brain-fart of epic proportions. I hereby apologize profusely for this horrid blunder and would like to thank Sayt for pointing it out.

 

-Iron Palm Technique: Use Con-mod instead of Str-mod for unarmed strike damage. Not a fan per se, but okay.

 

-Magnified Spell: Increases maximum number of damage dice by 10 levels at the cost of 2 spell levels. This would e.g. allow a 20th level caster to cast 20d6 fireballs as 5th level spells. Does not work. Name 3 5th level spells, even among all 3pp books, that can deal AoE 20d6 at 5th level. Yeah, thought so. Delayed Blast Fireball is 7th level… Damage-output is off, broken.

 

-Martial Weapon Group Proficiency: Gain proficiency in all martial weapons. Can be taken as a rogue talent. Completely invalidates Martial Weapon Proficiency -textbook power-creep. Broken.

 

-Quick Sheath: Put a weapon away as a free action instead of as a move action. Dreamscarred Press’ version of the feat, Lightning Swap (Path of War, pg 23.), is more precise and better balanced, in spite of having an additional benefit. Ignore this iteration.

 

-Reflect Arrows: Return arrows to sender at -4 to atk and using Str-mod. This uses up an AoO. This feat isn’t bad (though wording is a bit non-standard), but its image is pretty ridiculous when used against BULLETS, arrows or bolts. Oh, and RAW, it can return rays and the like to sender as well. Broken.

-Second Skin: Wonky wording; reduces armor check penalty by 2, to a minimum of 0.

 

-Simple Weapon Group Proficiency: Become proficient with simple weapons. Only useful when playing commoners etc. Also: Redundant.

 

-Trader: +2 to Appraise and Linguistics, scaling to +4 at 10th level. Boring +2/+2 skill-feat. Filler.

 

-Underhanded Blow: When using Weapon Finesse, use Int-mod for damage instead of Str-mod. This is not increased by two-handed weapons, but oddly, it does not decrease for off-hand weapons, which makes this way of wielding them very complicated.

 

-Vicious Cleave: Use Vital Strike’s feat tree WHENEVER YOU CLEAVE. Since this does not require Vital Strike to trigger the cleave, you can abuse the hell out of this feat. Broken.

 

-Vicious Opportunity: Always Vital Strike when AoO-ing. Urgh. At least not as bad as the former.

 

-Vicious Spring Attack: This one works – lets you combine Spring Attack and Vital Strike. Nice!

 

-Wild Shape Shift: 1/wild shape, return to you humanoid form for druid level rounds. Shifting is a free action. Changing shape usually is a standard action. Very odd, pretty useless feat.

 

-Zealous Faith: Treat Warpriest blessing, priest dogma, cleric domain or inquisitor inquisition as +1 for corresponding powers. Comes with a no-early-access caveat. Solid.

 

Conclusion:

Editing and formatting are still good on a formal level. On a rules-level, there are quite a few non-standard wordings in here that are detrimental to the reader’s ability to properly understand the feats and some clear deviations that render RAW vs. RAI more nebulous than it should be. Layout adheres to a relatively elegant 2-column standard with a colored border and nice b/w-artworks. The pdf has no bookmarks, but doesn’t need them at this length.

 

This was one of Flaming Crab Games’ first offerings and the relative inexperience does show. Author Alex Abel has a decent grip on how general rules-wordings work – but the experience with the finer intricacies was obviously not (yet) there – there are a lot of feats in here that either are redundant, open issues in the rules-languages or ones that jam “fixes” (read: blatant power creeps) in. Which is unfortunate, for this pdf, on the other side, has some downright brilliant, cool ideas that render a few of the feats herein exceedingly fun indeed. That being said, the low asking price does also help to (somewhat) remedy this pdf. While still highly problematic in quite a few cases, an experienced GM can scavenge some small, but seriously cool gems from this crackerjack box. My final verdict will hence clock in at 2.5 stars, rounded down in spite of the low price and the newbie bonus – while there are gems in here, the majority of the feats herein has an issue or another.

 

You can get this inexpensive pdf here on OBS and here on d20pfsrd.com’s shop.

 

Endzeitgeist out.

Comments

  2 Responses to “Forgotten Core Feats (Revised)”

  1. On the subject of the “Extended [Class] Spell List”: The Wizard/Cleric/Druid spell lists are powerful, yes, but the more egregious aspects of their power lie in the very high level spells. A Bloodrager gaining a first, second, third and fourth level spell for a feat does not strike me as problematic, when a Bloodrager gets it’s fourth level spell twelve levels later than a wizard would. Secondly, there is a precedent for such a feat: Ultimate Magic‘s Unsanctioned Knowledge opened up the Cleric, Inquisitor and Bard spell lists for the Paladin. Thirdly, Bloodragers, Clerics and Rangers all automatically know their entire spell list, and prepare day-by-day, which answers the “Do they know” question.

    Defensive: Dodge bonuses to AC also apply to CMD, does this give the feat a total +4 to CMD?

    Firearm Mastery: With the ruling that a single stat may only be applied to damage once, and the ruling that you can’t fire two barrels as a single attack in a full attack, Firearms are not nearly as overpowered as they once were, especially as they are still extremely short-ranged (An abberant bloodrager can extend their melee reach beyond the 40ft area in which a flintlock pistol hits touch AC), are locked out of the best ranged feat (IMHO; Manyshot), and prone to exploding in one’s character’s hand, which I think counterbalances getting to hit and damage on the same stat.

    Intuitive Spellcaster: Spell levels are gained based on your full levels in that caster class, not based on your caster level. You example Paladin 4/Wizard 1 might have a wizard caster level of five, but he still only knows level one spells. (I may be misunderstanding, but this seems like a re-print of 3.5’s Practised Spellcaster).

    Vicious Cleave: Cleave and Vital strike are both (as far as I know) regarded as being strictly inferior to making full attacks. Considering Vital strike is an extra 7/14/21 (With a Greatsword, Normal/Improved/Greater) damage, I’d probably call this feat useless, rather than broken. I’d maybe consider taking this on one of my extremely niche silly-builds

    Respectfully,
    Sayt

    • Hej Sayt!

      Thank you for commenting!

      Re Extended Spell Lists: Unsanctioned Magics isn’t a good example as a precedent – the paladin’s spell list is already strong, though in particularly the bard’s as added is nasty. I still believe them to be strong, getting stronger the more books you use and not well done; Bloodragers, Palas and Rangers already have rather neat spells; allowing them to scavenge in the most widely open spell-lists is not something I’d endorse. Also: Bloodragers do NOT have access to all spells.

      “To learn or cast a spell, a bloodrager must have a Charisma score […] The bloodrager does not need to prepare these spells in advance; he can cast any spell he knows at any time, assuming he hasn’t yet used up his allotment of spells per day for the spell’s level. […] The bloodrager’s selection of spells is limited. At 4th level, a bloodrager knows two 1st-level spells of his choice.” etc.

      Defensive: I assumed so, yes. One instance where the wording could have been clearer, but for once, id di not penalize the book for this.

      Firearm Mastery: You’d be right in the assertion that the rulings did nerf firearms somewhat. Reloading as a free action still makes them exceedingly brutal. While their range sucks and always has sucked, mid-range touch-AC full attacks really annihilate a lot of opposition and with this feat, you’ll be blunderbussing/musketing like crazy, when internally, the rules themselves presume the reload to be what makes them less prone to abuse. Personally, I really don’t like the base mechanics too much, but for one feat, this one’s bonus is rather brutal.

      Intuitive Spellcaster: I profusely apologize for this colossal misread on my behalf. 🙁 Can’t really explain it and am very thankful you pointed this one out – I’m only human and I can’t believe this one slipped past.

      Re Vicious Cleave: Yes, they are considered to be inferior to full attacks, with one crucial difference: Vital Strike and Vicious Cleave can be used when moving, while full attacks mean a standstill. This makes a pretty big difference in tactical combats. At least in most of the games I know, there is quite a lot of movement, which makes this one stronger.

      Thank you for pointing out the Intuitive Spellcaster-failure on my part and for your take on the respective feats!!! 😀

      All the best!!!

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Connect with Facebook

(required)

(required)