Dec 182014
 

Prestige Archetypes – The Eldritch Knight

132118

This installment of the Prestige Archetype-series clocks in at 8 pages, 1 page front cover, 1 page SRD, ~1/2 a page of editorial, leaving us with 5 1/2 pages of content, so let’s take a look!

 

First question – what are prestige archetypes? Well, they are essentially a breakdown of a regular PrC into a full-blown 20-level spanning class – so no, these classes don’t necessarily mean that you’ll have a universal archetype (wouldn’t have worked in this context, I think), instead providing a retooled playing experience so you don’t have to work your way up to the PrC via classes you don’t want to play. So that’s definitely a pro-side. On the con-side, *personally*, I treat PrCs as very much tied to organizations etc., emphasizing the “prestige”-component as opposed to archetypes, which are more traditions in my game. I’m not the target audience of these books, but I will take a stab at them anyways.

 

The Eldritch knight base class as provided herein received d8, 3/4 BAB-progression, good fort- and will-saves, 2 +Int skills per level, proficiency with simple and martial weapons and all armor and shields, though they retain arcane spell failure chances. They also may cast prepared arcane spells of up to 9th spell level via int from the sorc/wiz list. The class counts as both fighter and wizard-levels for the purpose of level requirements. At 1st level, the eldritch knight also has to choose either an arcane school or an arcane bond. At 3rd level and every 3 levels thereafter, the eldritch knight also receives a bonus feat that can be selected from item creation, metamagic, combat etc. -and arcane discoveries. The latter option makes me swallow somewhat, due to an increased frequency of bonus feats when compared to that of the wizard and thus also an increased array of arcane discoveries.

 

Spellcasting-wise, the class starts with1 cantrip and 1st level spell, but increases the amount of slots per day slower than the wizard, losing about 2 levels of spells gained over the 20 levels of the class on the non-martial brethren. The signature capstone spell critical of the base PrC is gained at 15th level – alas, without fixing it. The ability still allows you to cast multiple round spells, full-round action spells etc. as one swift action when criting – which is broken in my book, even at this level..

 

The pdf also provides favored class options for the core-races, all of which are solid -and as courtesy to us DMs, we receive NPC-builds of an eldritch knight for levels 1, 5, 10 and 15 – kudos!

 

Now beyond that, the pdf also provides advice for players – extensive advice, to be precise, to deal with armored spellcasting and ways to make it work – pretty cool and nice, especially for less experienced/rules-savvy players!

 

Conclusion:
Editing and formatting are very good, I noticed no truly significant glitches. Layout adheres to Purple Duck Games printer-friendly two-column standard and the pdf comes fully bookmarked for your convenience.

Carl Cramér has done mercifully a job beyond what was required; The base Eldritch Knight PrC is utterly bland, sans identity and some would argue, bad – qualifying for it sucks and it does not provide any cool, unique tricks to pull off beyond somewhat solid melee capacities and 9/10 spellcasting progression. The translation into a full base class thus can’t be faulted for being not particularly awe-inspiring. It does manage to adequately make the class both melee and caster at first level, though, and that without utterly outclassing the wizard colleagues – which is a good thing. The general take is more streamlined than the PrC and the option to take arcane discoveries helps bring the class somewhat closer to current Pathfinder’s rule-aesthetics as opposed to the beginnings of the system.

 

Now as you may have noticed, I do not like the base PrC. In fact, I loathe it as an example of boring PrC-design that should have died a fiery death in the inferno that consumed 3.X. BUT, this is not about my personal preference; after all, I’m pretty sure that some of you like the class, perhaps prefer it over the magus. And as a reviewer, I have to respect that and at least try to provide an objective stance on this one – and it’s better than the base PrC. In spite of the meager base materials provided by the PrC, this one should be considered the superior take and perhaps even a class that has a reason to exist in current PFRPG, with the thankfully streamlined saves and refreshment making the concept seem less like a systemic anachronism. And for that, in spite of my utter disdain of the class mechanics this is based on, in spite of the still flawed spell critical, I’ll have to rate this 4 stars. Congratulations, Mr Cramér – I don’t often get to rate a product this strongly against my own personal inclinations.

 

You can get this nice take on the Eldritch knight here on OBS and here on d20pfsrd.com’s shop.

 

Endzeitgeist out.

Comments

  2 Responses to “Prestige Archetypes – The Eldritch Knight”

  1. Thank you for evaluating the prestige archetypes fairly despite disliking the base concept. In my defense, we added a note on how to let a player “earn” a prestige archetype in play, tough the eldrich knight is probably one of the harder ones to apply that rule to.

    > The signature capstone spell critical of the base PrC is gained at 15th level – alas, without fixing it. The ability still allows you to cast multiple round spells, full-round action spells etc. as one swift action when criting – which is broken in my book, even at this level..

    Thank you, duly noted, will look into this for the version in the compilation. It is very easy to read a text with “reasonable assumptions” – “fixing” things in your mind that are broken in the raw. I worked to avoid that but failed here.

    /Author

    • Hej Carl!

      First of all: Thank you for commenting!
      I absolutely concur with your observations – you had next to nil to work with and what you made out of the PrC is really, really nice considering that. Now as for spell critical – may I suggest limiting the casting of spells via spell critical to spells with an unmodified casting duration of a standard action or lesser?

      Another thing, while I have your attention – I did not look forward to reviewing this series, mainly because you were an unknown designer AND the base PrCs are imho rather broken anachronisms of an bygone era. So far, you have, more often that not, demonstrated a good grasp of rules and provided general improvements. Your assassin, for example? Sold. Went right into my “classes eligible for main campaign”-folder. 🙂

      So yeah, kudos, and expect *a lot* more PA-reviews. All files of subscription 1 are in the draft 2.0 stage, which is one step to publication.

      Cheers and all the best!
      Thilo

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Connect with Facebook

(required)

(required)